Start With A Defined Question
“How much am I up?” can refer to an open position, completed sales, a strategy budget or a whole account. These are different scopes. A useful figure needs a currency, a valuation time, an included set of positions and a denominator. Keep those definitions beside the number before comparing it with another screen.
For a simple long position, unrealized profit or loss is the marked value of the remaining shares minus their remaining cost basis. A mark is the price used to value holdings; it is not a confirmed sale. A broker may use its own pricing and accounting conventions. Tradexers' stock P/L view labels unrealized results; it should not be interpreted as a complete tax or account-return report.
Follow The Shares Through A Sale
Consider a hypothetical position of ten shares bought for $20 each, with no fees. The starting cost is $200. If four shares are sold for $23, the proceeds are $92. Using a simple average-cost illustration, those four shares carry $80 of cost, so realized P/L is $12. The remaining six shares carry $120 of cost.
If the remaining shares are marked at $22, their marked value is $132 and unrealized P/L is $12. Combining $12 realized with $12 unrealized gives $24 of gross P/L for this example. It does not mean another $24 of cash was received. Only the sale generated proceeds; the rest depends on a future exit. This illustration is not a tax-lot election or a statement about a particular broker's accounting.
- Initial Purchase
- 10 × $20 = $200 cost
- Completed Sale
- 4 × $23 − $80 allocated cost = $12 realized
- Remaining Position
- 6 × $22 − $120 remaining cost = $12 unrealized
- Combined Gross P/L
- $12 + $12 = $24
No commissions, fees, dividends, taxes, currency conversion or borrowing costs are included.
Make The Percentage Reproducible
The same $24 can produce different percentages. Relative to the original $200 position cost it is 12%. Relative to a $1,000 strategy budget it is 2.4%. Both calculations are arithmetically valid, but they answer different questions. Label the denominator and avoid comparing either directly with a time-weighted or annualized return.
The Tradexers bot ledger combines its recorded realized and marked unrealized P/L, then divides by the assigned bot budget for its return percentage. That budget-based figure is a strategy view rather than the brokerage account's total performance. A bot's budget is not the same as account equity, available cash or a guaranteed maximum loss.
Cash flows also matter. If an account moves from $1,000 to $1,500 after a $500 deposit, the value increase alone does not show an investment gain. A defensible account-return calculation needs the amounts and timing of deposits, withdrawals and relevant income. A snapshot without those inputs cannot resolve that question.
Reconcile Before Drawing Conclusions
Start with the broker's positions and completed fills, then compare quantities, cost basis, valuation times and currencies. Keep pending orders separate from executed activity. A missing quote or cost value is missing information; displaying zero would create a misleading gain or loss. Group totals should combine compatible quantities and currencies.
For an economic result, include the costs and income relevant to the question. FINRA's return explanation shows why purchase/sale costs and income affect the outcome. This guide's simplified ledger deliberately omits them. Use official broker statements and suitable professional advice for tax reporting or disputes rather than treating an app calculation as authoritative.
- Name the scope and valuation time
- Separate realized from unrealized P/L
- State the percentage denominator
- Account for cash flows and omitted costs
- Resolve differences against broker records
Sources & Scope
Primary references support the factual background. Calculations, examples and research routines are original educational illustrations. App descriptions reflect this guide's update date; provider terms and availability can change.
Suggest A Correction